Category: Engineering Expert Witness
-
Engineering Expert Was Not Allowed to Opine on the Condition of the Wooden Panel
This is a personal injury case. Plaintiff Amy Manzanares was allegedly injured by a wooden panel in Defendant El Monte Rents, Inc.’s recreational vehicle (“RV”) in November 2023. Defendant filed a motion to exclude Plaintiffs’ expert, Mark Goodson, P.E. Engineering Expert Witness Mark E. Goodson, P.E. is a consulting engineer licensed in electrical and mechanical…
-
Engineering Expert Allowed to Opine on Property Damage
Plaintiff R&J Components filed this action for negligence, alleging damage to inventory during roof renovations. Centimark Corporation and SIU Professional Roofing LLC (“Defendants”) sought to exclude Plaintiff’s damages expert, Mikey Minor, under Rule 702 of the Federal Rules of Evidence. Engineering Expert Witness Mikey Minor is a director of consulting and lead consulting engineer with…
-
Engineering Expert Barred From Opining on the Sidewalk Condition
In this facially simple premises liability lawsuit, Plaintiff Stephanie Lewis sought to recover damages incurred when she tripped and fell on the front walkway of Samuel B. Heggie, Jr.’s home while she was delivering a pizza in February 2020. Samuel Heggie having died during the pendency of this lawsuit, the Plaintiff now proceeds against the…
-
Engineering Expert Was Allowed to Opine on the Ruptured Pipe
Plaintiffs, BME Fire Trucks LLC (“BME”) and 223 Roedel Avenue LLC’s (“Roedel”), brought this action against their insurer, Defendant The Cincinnati Casualty Company (“Cincinnati”), seeking damages caused by a ruptured natural gas pipeline. On October 31, 2022, BME submitted a claim to Cincinnati, and Cincinnati retained Brian Hansen of Northwest Investigative Engineering to inspect the…
-
Engineering Expert’s Testimony on the Lack of a Clean-Out Tool Excluded
Plaintiff David Vakili alleged that a snow thrower was defective because its design lacked a simple safety feature—a cleanout tool. To help prove his case, Vakili enlisted the support of Jack Krafchick, P.E., who authored an expert report finding the subject snow thrower defective and the cause of Vakili’s injuries. Defendants MTD Products Inc. and…
-
Engineering Expert’s Theory of Damages Excluded
Plaintiff Leflore County Board of Supervisors filed suit against Meritor over a state-approved waste disposal that occurred almost two decades ago. In 2006, Meritor’s predecessor, ArvinMeritor, sent some waste to Plaintiff’s landfill (the “Landfill”) as part of a state-approved cleanup of the Moose Lodge Road Disposal Area (“MLRDA”). And now, almost two decades later,Plaintiff claimed…
-
Engineering Expert’s Testimony on an Unsafe Walking Surface Admitted
This is a premises liability action in which the Plaintiff Natasha Walkowicz Shea (“Plaintiff’) sought to hold the Defendants, Kalahari Resorts & Conventions-Poconos; Kalahari Resorts, PA, LLC; and Kalahari Resorts, LLC (hereinafter, collectively, “Kalahari”) liable in negligence for her alleged injuries sustained as a result of slipping and falling on snow and/or ice in a…
-
Engineering Expert’s Testimony on Metal Roofing Degradation Admitted
This case is a breach of good faith and fair dealing and breach of contract due to Defendant CSAA General Insurance Company denying Plaintiff George Richardson’s roof damage claim that occurred on September 23, 2023. Defendant filed a Daubert motion to exclude the testimony of Plaintiff’s expert witness, Michael Pruitt. Engineering Expert Witness Michael Pruitt,…
-
Engineering Expert’s Opinions on Seats and Restraints Excluded
This action arises from injuries sustained by Christopher Fabricant, a 52-year-old pelvic surgeon, while riding the Kingda Ka rollercoaster at the Six Flags amusement park located in Jackson, New Jersey. Defendants challenged the admissibility of Plaintiffs’ expert Edward M. Pribonic, who was retained to “conduct an engineering review and mechanical analysis to determine the mechanisms…
-
Construction Expert Barred from Testifying on Established Damages
The case arises from Belmere, L.P.’s claim that Steadfast Insurance Company failed to timely and adequately pay it proceeds due under its commercial lines policy after Belmere invested $26 million of its own funds to repair a 249-unit apartment complex in Houma, Louisiana that it alleged suffered “catastrophic damage” during Hurricane Ida. Through its lawsuit, Belmere…
