Category: Expert Challenges
-
Legal Conclusions Do Not Necessitate the Wholesale Exclusion of Insurance Expert Witness’ Testimony
Plaintiff Ashley Fawcett was in a car accident in 2017, while she was covered by an insurance policy issued by Defendant Standard Fire Insurance Company (doing business as Travelers Insurance Company (“Travelers”)). Fawcett opened claims with Travelers, and alleged in this lawsuit that Travelers unreasonably investigated and evaluated her claim for underinsured motorist (“UIM”) benefits.…
-
Civil Engineering Expert Witness’ Opinion that the Roof Requires Full Replacement is Not Mere Speculation
Plaintiff Franklin Square Condominium Owner Association alleged that a hailstorm on April 28, 2021, damaged its property at 817-831 Old Ranch Road 12, San Marcos, Texas 78666. Franklin Square filed a claim with its insurance company, Defendant AmGuard Insurance Company. Plaintiff alleged that AmGuard breached the insurance contract by failing to pay the full amount…
-
Radiology Expert Witness’ Specific Findings As to the Plaintiff’s Spine Area Admitted
On December 9, 2021, Plaintiff Darryl Everson was driving in Montz, Louisiana, when he claimed that Defendant David Rugg (“Rugg”) negligently felled a tree along the roadway. The Plaintiff contended that the tree landed on his car, causing injuries to his back and neck. Additionally, Plaintiff alleged that Rugg was employed by Defendant Romesberg Trucking…
-
Industrial Hygiene Expert Witness’ Testimony Regarding the Mitigation Performed Admitted
Plaintiff, MacNair, owned the immovable property located at 526-528 Belleville Street, New Orleans, Louisiana 70114 which she insured through Chubb. MacNair lived on one side of her home and rented out the other side. On August 29, 2021, Hurricane Ida caused severe damage to MacNair’s property including the roof, all elevations and all rooms in…
-
Construction Expert Witness Used Objective Grounds to Come to his Conclusions
VEC, Inc. accused Joyce Electrical Inc. and Hudson Insurance Co. of breaching a building contract between the parties, after Williams Field Service Company LLC awarded VEC a contract to build an electrical substation and distribution line. After soliciting bids for subcontractors to do the electrical work on the project, VEC hired Joyce. Joyce eventually fell…
-
Defendant Was Not Justified in Failing to Disclose Orthopedic Sports Medicine Expert Witness’ Report Regarding the Plaintiff’s Medical Condition
Plaintiff Deana Hosie alleges that, on November 17, 2017, while dining at the Defendant Omni Hotels Management Corporation’s hotel restaurant, she tripped and fell over a box-shaped object on the floor, causing her serious injuries. After disclosing expert Charles DePaolo, M.D., the Defendant indicated that DePaolo would not provide a report until “after his forthcoming independent…
-
Proposed Expert Witnesses Barred from Evaluating Psychological and Economic Damages
Domski filed this lawsuit on August 11, 2023, alleging that she was wrongfully terminated from her employment by defendant Blue Cross Blue Shield of Michigan after she refused to comply with the company’s COVID-19 vaccination policy. Domski worked for Blue Cross Blue Shield from March 10, 2008 until her termination on January 5, 2022, most…
-
Medical Billing Expert Witness’ Testimony Does Not Breach Georgia’s Collateral Source Rule
This case arises from a high-speed, single vehicle collision into a tree. After the collision, the vehicle caught fire and exploded. Plaintiff Jade Burch was the front seat passenger in the vehicle. As a result of the collision, Burch broke her pelvis, femur, tibia, and seven ribs. She required emergency leg surgery. Burch also suffered…
-
Vocational Rehabilitation Expert Witness’ Testimony Admitted Because he used Data from Industry-Specific Sources
This is an action for Jones Act negligence, unseaworthiness and unpaid maintenance and cure brought by Eric Ward. On or about December 13, 2021, Ward joined the Yacht as the Electro Technical Officer as part of the Yacht’s engineering department in Miami Beach, Florida at a private residence. On night of December 23, 2021, the…
-
Legal Ethics Expert Witness’ Opinions Regarding a Conflict of Interest on Coverage Admitted
Plaintiff, Ansur America Insurance Company, sued Defendants, James A. Borland and Quinn, Johnston, Henderson & Pretorious, Chtd., an experienced defense lawyer and his law firm, for alleged legal malpractice in handling a complex product liability case in St. Clair County, Illinois. Plaintiff alleged that Defendants failed to meet the standard of care in representing Plaintiff…
