Category: Expert Challenges
-
Court reserves ruling on the motion to exclude after the expert’s opinion is found to consist of legal questions for the Court
Plaintiff, Racine Car Dealer, LLC, (“Racine” or “RCD”) a former Hyundai and Genesis motor vehicle dealer, claimed that Defendant, Hyundai Motor America(“HMA”) deceived it, withheld information, and altered the rules and policies of Hyundai’s dealer incentive program without notice. This alleged conduct compelled the Plaintiff to terminate the Genesis side of its dealership before completing…
-
Expert found qualified to opine on the Overall Completeness of the Stage Prop based on his experience in Construction Management and Operations
The case originated from a contract disagreement between Movie Prop Rentals LLC and Miami Prop Rentals LLC, businesses in the movie production sector, and The Kingdom of God Global Church, a not-for-profit religious organization. The Plaintiffs claimed that the Defendants did not fulfill their part of a contract concerning the design and construction of a…
-
Court precludes the expert from offering an opinion on someone else’s subjective beliefs or feelings
Vincent McKinney’s death on April 15, 2021, at a U-Haul construction site led to a lawsuit, filed by his surviving spouse and next kin Alberta Louise Perry, Plaintiff, with Jenkins & Stiles, LLC, a construction company and the general contractor for the site, being the Defendant. Despite some disputed facts, parties agreed that McKinney, who…
-
Expert’s Lack of Knowledge and Experience more specific to Product Design found to carry a grave risk of juror confusion
In March 2022, Defendants Edition Modern and Denis De La Mésière faced a lawsuit filed by Plaintiffs Jean Royère SAS and Jelena Markovic. Edition Modern, a small business, operated with approximately three full-time employees, including both owners and a few part-time workers. Denis De La Mésière, one of the owners, possessed over 40 years of…
-
Court Excludes the Testimony of Safety Expert Witness after it Fails to Assist the Jury
This case involved a lawsuit filed by the Plaintiff Daniel G. Mann against Defendant Quiktrip Corporation for negligence related to a slip and fall incident. On July 20, 2022, the Plaintiff initiated legal proceedings by filing a Petition in the Circuit Court of St. Louis County. The complaint alleged common law negligence against Quiktrip in…
-
Court rejects lost revenue calculations proffered by Valuation Expert Witness citing lack of consistency with Missouri contract damages law
This legal scenario revolves around a dispute between newspaper carriers, Bextermueller News Distributors, Inc., and Tom Richards, and the Defendants, Lee Enterprises, Inc., Lee Enterprises Missouri, Inc., Pulitzer, Inc., St. Louis Post-Dispatch, LLC. The carriers had agreements granting them exclusive rights to deliver St. Louis Post-Dispatch newspapers in specified geographic areas. Allegedly, the Defendants breached…
-
Court limits the testimony of Chemical Engineering Expert Witness after it is found to consist of an improper legal opinion
This case arose from a fire at the vacant home of Richard F. Vetter and Bryan Miner (collectively, “Plaintiffs”) on March 9, 2021. The Plaintiffs were renovating their home and had applied Varathane Classic Wood Stain, manufactured by Defendant Rust-Oleum Corporation, to their wood floors. After applying the stain, they left the applicators saturated in…
-
Court admits the opinions of opposing experts about standard of care exercised to treat burn injuries in flight
This is a claim for damages under Article 17 and Article 21 of the Montreal Convention concerning an incident that occurred on February 11, 2022, during a JetBlue international flight from Orlando, Florida, to Montego Bay, Jamaica. The Plaintiff Julian Buonomo (“Buonomo”) sustained serious injuries when hot water spilled on his right arm and flank.…
-
Court limits certain conclusions of Accident Reconstruction Expert Witness deemed “unsupported” and “misleading”
This case arose from a motor vehicle accident on Interstate 55 in Scott County, Missouri. Plaintiffs Benjamin Behel, David Wallace, and Joye Wallace filed a lawsuit against Defendants Berney Wescott, Heritage Transport LLC, Bobby James, and Tracy Reynolds for damages sustained in the accident. Behel was driving southbound in the right lane with an attached…
-
Court rejects estimates proffered by the Construction Expert Witness citing credibility concerns
This lawsuit originated from the damage Hurricane Laura caused to First United Pentecostal Church of DeRidder (FUPC), a church in DeRidder, Louisiana, on August 27, 2020. Throughout the relevant period, the church was insured under a policy issued by Church Mutual Insurance Company (Church Mutual). Following the storm, FUPC engaged in a contract with Plaintiff…
