Tag: Expert Testimony
-
Architecture Expert’s Opinions on Causation and Damages Admitted
Plaintiffs Michael Gerstman and Marie Webster, the insureds, sued Defendant Crestbrook Insurance Company (“Crestbrook”), their insurer, to recover on contractual and extracontractual theories arising from Crestbrook’s denial of their claim in this storm damage insurance coverage dispute. Crestbrook filed a motion to strike the testimony of Plaintiffs’ experts, Dr. Neil Hall and Kevin Funsch. Architecture…
-
Advertising Expert Permitted to Testify on Impact of Coupon Discounts on Consumer Decision-Making
Michaels Stores, Inc. sells arts and crafts and home decor products on its website and in its stores. Plaintiff, Nea Vizcarra, purchased several items from Michaels.com on November 28, 2022. Vizcarra said that in purchasing the discounted items, she understood that she was purchasing items that regularly (including before the advertised promotion) retailed at the…
-
Psychology Expert’s Testimony on the Process of Memory Formation Admitted
In October 2019, Nan Morgan McCartney was severely burned while attempting to start a fire in her backyard firepit. She used a plastic gasoline container manufactured by Scepter. McCartney has given multiple different accounts of the incident over time, but the most recent account (in her deposition) is that she was trying to pour gas from…
-
Recreational Vehicle Expert’s Cost-of-Repair Opinion Admitted
Naomi and Christopher Pershing (and their revocable Pecan Trust) sought compensation from Nexus RVs, LLC and Navistar, Inc. for their recreational vehicle, which they called defective. Nexus offered Thomas Fribley as an opinion witness. On March 14, 2025, the Pershings filed a motion to exclude an opinion from Fribley under Federal Rule of Evidence 702…
-
Testimony of Rehabilitation Expert Admitted Despite Reliance on Medical Opinions
This is a personal-injury action arising out of a motor-vehicle accident between Plaintiff Jose Ricardo Olvera-Velazquez and Defendant Jose Hernandez De La Rosa. Defendant MVT Transportation LLC (“MVT”) has stipulated that Defendant De La Rosa was acting in the course and scope of his employment with MVT at the time of the accident. According to…
-
ASL Expert’s Testimony on Language Proficiency Excluded
Marie Rose Lennox Wing was deaf and used American Sign Language (“ASL”) to communicate. She passed away after three visits to Dignity Health hospitals over the course of a month. Her estate and family members brought this lawsuit following her death. It argued that Dignity Health violated state and federal law by requiring family members…
-
Expert’s Legal Conclusions Advocating for Class Certification Excluded
This putative class action was initiated by Plaintiffs, a group of individuals who are leaseholders of oil and gas leases, against Defendant XTO Energy Inc (“XTO”) alleging that XTO breached their leases when it deducted unreasonable and excessive post-production costs from their royalty payments. Therefore, XTO filed a motion to exclude certain opinions of Plaintiffs’…
-
Orthopedic Surgery Expert’s Opinions About an Aggravation of Pre-Existing Degenerative Disc Disease Admitted
Plaintiff Myles Childress brought his claims against Defendant Wal-Mart Stores East I, LP. after he allegedly sustained injuries while delivering goods to a Walmart store in Bridgeton, Missouri. Plaintiff raised claims against both Defendant Walmart and Walmart’s employee, an unknown Doe Defendant. Dr. Richard Kube is an orthopedic spine surgeon practicing in Peoria, Illinois. Defendant argued…
-
Mental Health Expert’s PTSD Diagnosis Was Deemed Reliable
The claims against La-Norma Ramirez and Washington County stem from Plaintiff Danyale Blackmore’s booking and release at the Washington County Jail. Blackmore alleged that her constitutional rights were violated when she was allegedly strip-searched at the Jail. Elisabeth York was disclosed to address Danyale’s mental health symptoms and her diagnosis of posttraumatic stress disorder (PTSD).…
-
Police Practices Expert’s Use-of-Force Opinions Excluded
Plaintiff Deven Barrette (“Plaintiff) brings this action against Defendants the Village of Swanton; Kyle Gagne (“Defendant Gagne”); Jordan M. Mosher (“Defendant Mosher”); Robert Recore (“Defendant Recore”); and Leonard Stell (“Defendant Stell”); as well as John and Jane Does I-X (the “Doe Defendants”). Plaintiff’s claims arose from his detention by Swanton Village Police Department (“SVPD”) officers on…