Tag: standard of care
-
Gastroenterology Expert Witness’ Testimony Is Not Supported By An Explanation Of the Principles and Methods
Plaintiffs, Kathian Marie López-Concepción and Lenymar López-Concepción sought to recover damages for the alleged wrongful death of their late father, Angel I. López-Diaz in this medical malpractice action. Plaintiffs alleged in their complaint that the medical treatment and care provided by CMC, Dr. Benny Nieves Matias, Dr. Iolani Garcia Rosario, and Dr. Cristina I. Ortiz…
-
Opinions of Walkway Safety Expert Witness on Hazard and Standard of Care Excluded
Plaintiff Logan Demboske (“Demboske”) alleged in this premises liability action that he slipped and fell on or about January 30, 2023, on “a transitory foreign substance.” Demboske has retained David Collette as a walkway expert. In Collette’s expert report, he contended that Demboske slipped and fell on a liquid contaminant on a vinyl floor, coated…
-
Drug Enforcement Expert Witness Allowed To Testify Despite Not Being A Pharmacist
Manes is a pharmacy that has served the Van Buren, Arkansas community for nearly 40 years. AmerisourceBergen is a wholesale distributor of pharmaceutical products, including controlled substances. This dispute arises from AmerisourceBergen’s decision to restrict its sale of controlled substances to Manes. Manes sued AmerisourceBergen for breach of contract, tortious interference with Manes’ business expectancies,…
-
Product Safety Expert Witness’ Testimony Admitted Despite Alleged Lack of Familiarity with Tree Stands
Plaintiff, James Rowedder alleged a Field & Stream Stealth Climber Tree stand HEH01293 (“tree stand”) manufactured by Defendant Primal Vantage Company, Inc. (“Primal”) and sold by Defendant Dick’s Sporting Goods, Inc. d/b/a Field & Stream failed while Rowedder was using it and that he sustained injuries as a result. Plaintiff brought claims for (1) Negligence—Product Defect;…
-
Safety Expert Witness’ Testimony on Situational Awareness and Duty of Care Rejected
A district judge in Oklahoma noted the expert witness’ extensive background in event safety at live events but barred him from testifying because he never inspected the area where Plaintiff fell and ignored relevant statutes and codes. Plaintiff Boulac sought damages for injuries she allegedly sustained at the Bank of Oklahoma Center (“BOK Center”) in…
-
Business Valuation Expert Witness’ Assessment of Whether the CFO’s Actions Conformed with the Standard Conduct Rejected
A district judge in Florida limited the testimony of a Business Valuation Expert Witness because he did not identify how exactly the CFO breached his unidentified standard of care. This case arises out of Nextplat’s termination of its former Chief Financial Officer (“CFO”), Thomas Seifert. Nextplat contended in its Second Amended Complaint (among other things)…
-
Nursing Expert Witness Fails to Establish Breach of Duty of Care
A district judge in Kansas barred an expert physician and nurse from testifying about the Defendants’ deviation from the requisite standard of care. Facts: On April 9, 2021, Smoky Hill admitted Arlen Dority, age 82, after a fall at his home on April 6, 2021 and a decline in his ability to care for himself.…
-
Court rejects Life Care Planning Expert Witness’ testimony concerning future medical expenses for surgical treatment and related care in underinsured motorist bad faith action
In an underinsured motorist (“UIM”) bad faith action stemming from a car accident, Todd Cope presented at the emergency room after his vehicle was rear-ended on November 6, 2013, citing complaints of occipital headache, pain behind his right eye, and cervical spine pain. Medical records at that time indicated no acute traumatic injuries to the…
-
Experts are free to rely upon the opinions of other experts; Court limits the testimony of the Chiropractic Expert Witness on account of drawing impermissible conclusions
This case arises from a stroke allegedly caused by a chiropractic adjustment performed by Dr. Frederick Stinner. In February 2015, Justin Brutosky began experiencing chronic back, neck, and head pain. To treat these issues, he periodically saw Stinner, a chiropractor at Madison Avenue Chiropractic Center. From early 2015 to September 17, 2018, Stinner performed 39…
-
Texas Court admits medical expert testimony in prenatal care medical malpractice case
Discover the intricacies of expert witness testimony admissibility in a medical malpractice case. Explore how qualifications, relevance, and reliability of experts play a pivotal role in legal proceedings. Delve into the Daubert standard and the key takeaways from a recent case involving medical experts in obstetrics, gynecology, and pediatrics.