Tag: Testing
-
Court Cannot Conclude that Environmental Science Expert Witness’ Opinions Meet the Rule 702 Standard
Plaintiff Utah Physicians for a Healthy Environment’s (“UPHE”) alleged a number of Clean Air Act (“CAA”) and Noise Control Act (“NCA”) violations against Defendants, who are motorcycle dealerships and their owner. At summary judgment, UPHE proffered the expert testimony of Dr. Michael St. Denis. In relevant part, St. Denis opined that a “test motorcycle” purchased…
-
Electrical Engineering Expert Witness’ Testimony Admitted Despite Lack of Independent Testing
Raytheon Company (“Raytheon” or “Plaintiff”) is a large, international military and defense contractor holding several prime contracts with the United States Government. At their Fairdale location Raytheon maintains, stores, and services multiple mobile charging stations and storage locations for lithium-ion battery boxes (“LBBs”). The LBB’s were designed and manufactured by Saft but owned by the…
-
Human Factors Expert Witness’ Ergonomics Analysis Not Fully Excluded Despite Alleged Lack of Testing
Stephen Ratcliffe has brought a lawsuit against BRP, the manufacturer, and Tidd’s Sport Shop, Inc. (Tidd’s), the dealer, of a 2019 Can-Am Maverick X3, a utility terrain vehicle (UTV), asserting negligence and strict liability claims arising out of an incident in which Ratcliffe’s Maverick X3 rolled onto its side and crushed his arm. The Plaintiff…
-
Pain Management Expert Witness’ Testimony About Billing for Medical Examinations Admitted
This matter involves the Plaintiff insurers’ claim that Defendants unlawfully billed for medically unnecessary and illusory services, misrepresented the nature and extent of the services, and operated in violation of various laws specific to the healthcare and/or insurance sector. According to the Plaintiff, Titan Defendants agreed to refer patients to the Stein Defendants in exchange…
-
FDA Expert Witness’ Testimony Excluded Because He Did Not Test His Theories
The Plaintiffs — Carmelo Leon and Wanda Leon — brought this action against the Defendants — United Industries Corporation (“UIC”), Spectrum Brands, Inc. (“SBI”), Cutter, and Home Depot U.S.A., Inc. (“Home Depot”) — after Carmelo Leon sustained burn injuries during an incident involving a mosquito-repelling candle manufactured and sold by the Defendants. The Defendants initially moved…
-
Design Engineering Expert Witness’ Product Defect Theory held to be Reliable
A district judge in New Jersey decided that a design engineering expert witness could testify about the alleged design defects of the model in question and the risks and possible outcomes of such design defects. On August 19, 2016, William Visakay (“Visakay”) was riding his 2007 Craftsman Lawn Tractor in his backyard when it overturned…
-
Testimony of Mechanical Engineering Expert Witnesses Held to be Based on Thorough Review and Adequate Testing of the Product
Plaintiff India Smith (“Plaintiff”) filed this product liability lawsuit against Tabletops Unlimited, Inc. d/b/a TTU’s (“TTU”) on August 1, 2022. Plaintiff sought to recover damages from an August 24, 2020 incident in which she sustained burns on her chest, upper abdomen, and legs after her Pressure Cooker ejected hot contents on her when she tried to open…
-
Slip Resistance Testing Conducted by Biomechanical Engineering Expert Witness Deemed Reliable
The Plaintiffs alleged that on December 24, 2020, Dr. Bruce Bunting slipped and fell outside the automatic exit doors at the CVS Store. Bunting claimed that he slipped on “slick and wet concrete that resulted from a mixture of salt and water.” The Plaintiffs alleged that CVS Pharmacy, LLC created the slick surface by “spreading…
