Tag: Unreliable
-
Expert Testimony on Legal Ethics Excluded
Robert I. Toussie alleged that he and his brother Michael entered into an agreement (the “Participation Agreement”) with Coastal Development, LLC (“Coastal”), an entity run by Richard Fields in 2000 to finance the development of casinos in Florida. However, Coastal/Fields promptly, and repeatedly, breached the terms of the Participation Agreement by not paying the Toussies…
-
Accident Reconstruction Expert’s Testimony on Human Factors Excluded
This case arises from a fatal automobile accident that occurred on September 22, 2017. Blake Haddox was traveling southbound on a motorcycle as Defendant Nicholas Roshon Moore drove a semi-truck in a northbound lane and turned left across traffic. The two collided, and Haddox died as a result. Plaintiffs planned to present the testimony and opinions of…
-
Transportation Safety Expert’s Testimony on Compliance with Federal Safety Regulations Admitted
This case concerns a motor vehicle collision that occurred between Plaintiff Bryan Russell Arnett (“Plaintiff”) and Defendant Larry Tyrone Fairell, II (“Fairell”) on December 14, 2022. Fairell filed a motion to partially strike the testimony of Arnett’s retained transportation safety expert, David Hedgpeth. Transportation Safety Expert Witness David Hedgpeth is the principal owner of Hill…
-
Expert Testimony on Legitimate Marketing Practices Admitted
The Federal Trade Commission contended that Amazon tricked, coerced, and manipulated consumers into subscribing to Amazon Prime. According to the FTC, this was accomplished by failing to disclose the material terms of the subscription clearly and conspicuously and by failing to obtain the consumers’ informed consent before enrolling them. The FTC also alleged that Amazon…
-
Accident Reconstruction Expert’s Opinions About Visibility and Conditions at the Scene of the Accident Admitted
This case involves a rear-end collision between Plaintiff Tyler Brown’s sedan and a sprinter van driven by Defendant Nikolay Muzyka. The accident occurred during the early morning hours of July 29, 2021. Defendant Muzyka, who was driving in the far right lane, began to slow down as he saw lights from emergency vehicles ahead. As…
-
Statistics Expert’s Testimony on Discriminatory Employment Decisions Limited
The Plaintiffs had been employed by the Metropolitan Government of Nashville and Davidson County, Tennessee. They alleged in their lawsuits that, on May 4, 2020, they were either terminated or demoted for discriminatory reasons, and brought claims asserting many of the same legal violations. The Defendants filed two motions to exclude the testimony of Plaintiffs’…
-
Insurance Expert Allowed to Testify Regarding Industry Customs and Practices based on Experience
Plaintiff Jose Verdecia sustained injuries after falling through the ceiling of his home. He claims these injuries and other damages resulted from a misrepresentation by State Farm’s adjuster, Marvin Johnson, who allegedly instructed him to inspect the attic for damage, implying that his claim would be denied otherwise. To support his case, Plaintiff retained Earl…
-
Obstetrics and Gynecology Expert Witness’ Opinions on the Filshie Clip Instructions for Use Admitted
Defendants CooperSurgical, Inc., Femcare, Ltd., and Utah Medical Products, Inc. manufacture and distribute birth control devices called Filshie Clips. Filshie Clips are 3-5 millimeters wide and are laparoscopically placed on the fallopian tubes. Plaintiffs are individuals who had tubal ligation surgery in 2009 and 2010. Plaintiffs Giovanna Bulox and Lorena Ahiri Merlo are sisters. Bulox…
-
Mechanical Engineering Expert Witnesses’ Safer Alternative Forklift Designs Deemed Speculative
Plaintiff Deavrin Sneed (“Sneed”) filed this products liability case against Defendant Crown Equipment Corporation (“Crown”) after a workplace incident involving a Crown RC5500 Series stand-up rider forklift (the “subject forklift”). Crown’s RC5500 stand-up, side-stance forklifts are used to move palleted materials in warehouse facilities. When operating the forklift, the driver stands sideways with their hands on…
-
Fire Investigation Expert Witness Prohibited from Relying on Statements by an Unidentified Officer
Meadowbrook Shopping Plaza, LLC purchased a building at 3895 Metro Drive (“the Building”) in 1995. Around 2018, Mr. Khaldoun Abaji approached Meadowbrook about utilizing the Building for his business, a store called Kids Avenue. Abaji and Meadowbrook came to an oral agreement where Abaji paid Meadowbrook $800 a month for the space. The parties agreed…
