Category: Expert Challenges
-
Urogynecology Expert’s Opinion on Continuum of Care Admitted
Connie Thacker is one of tens of thousands of individuals who have filed suit against Ethicon for injuries after treatment with Ethicon’s pelvic mesh devices. Ethicon filed a motion to exclude or limit certain testimony of Thacker’s expert, Dr. Bruce A. Rosenzweig. Urogynecology Expert Witness Dr. Bruce Alan Rosenzweig is currently an Assistant Professor of…
-
Hepatology Expert’s Testimony About an Increased Risk of Liver Cancer Admitted
Wexford Health Sources, Inc. was the company hired by the State of Illinois to provide medical care to inmates across the state’s prison system. One of those inmates, Paul Daval, filed a lawsuit against certain Wexford employees, accusing them of showing deliberate indifference to his serious medical condition. Daval alleged that while he was incarcerated…
-
Economic Expert’s Opinions on Property Valuation Admitted in Cook County Tax Sale Case
Cook County ran an annual property tax sale targeting homeowners behind on property taxes. When taxes went unpaid, the County obtained court orders to sell tax liens on delinquent properties. Private tax buyers then paid the outstanding taxes in exchange for collecting repayment, plus interest, from property owners. If the owners didn’t repay within about…
-
Trademarks Expert’s Testimony on Fraudulent Procurement Excluded
This is a trademark infringement dispute between the franchisor, Spice Merchants Entities Corp., owned by Lisa Freeman, and its former franchisee, Pretty Colorado, owned by Corine Winslow. Freeman alleged violations of the “Breckenridge Tea & Spice” mark and claimed that Winslow and Pretty Colorado are using the same trade dress as the Spice franchises. Plaintiffs…
-
Engineering Expert’s Opinions on Seats and Restraints Excluded
This action arises from injuries sustained by Christopher Fabricant, a 52-year-old pelvic surgeon, while riding the Kingda Ka rollercoaster at the Six Flags amusement park located in Jackson, New Jersey. Defendants challenged the admissibility of Plaintiffs’ expert Edward M. Pribonic, who was retained to “conduct an engineering review and mechanical analysis to determine the mechanisms…
-
Marketing Expert’s Post-Sale Confusion Survey is Admissible
Think Green Limited (“Think Green”) has taken Medela AG and Medela LLC (“Medela”) to Court, accusing them of infringing on the trade dress rights it holds in its breast pump and misleading consumers through false advertising. Rhonda J. Harper, a Think Green expert witness in areas involving marketing, branding, and consumer research, used various analytical…
-
Psychology Expert’s Failure to Disclose Does Not Warrant Exclusion
Kiel Green fell to the ground after hitting the back of his elbow on a pallet of metal shelving while returning from a wooden wagon display containing beef jerky. At the time Green entered Atwood’s, Defendant was in the process of conducting a “reset” and various departments and merchandise were in the process of being…
-
Forensic Engineering Expert’s Testimony on Industry Safety Standards Admitted
Plaintiff Hui Wang brought suit against Omni Hotels Management seeking damages from a fall she suffered on September 25, 2018, in the lobby of the Omni New Haven Hotel at Yale. Wang alleged that she fell due to “water that had accumulated on the floor” and that Omni was negligent in allowing that water to…
-
Forensic Pathology Expert’s Conclusions About the Cause of Death Admitted
This suit arises from a motor vehicle accident that occurred on September 7, 2018, in Vinton, Louisiana. Plaintiffs alleged that Billy Smith was operating a 2016 Kenworth T880 while traveling westbound on Interstate 10 on that date. The vehicle was outfitted with Chinese-manufactured steel belt radial truck tires, distributed by CMA under the trade name…
-
Psychiatry Experts’ Opinions on Causation and Permanency Admitted
This action arises from the pled sexual assault of Plaintiff Margaret Betts by a massage therapist during an in-room massage appointment at Sixty LES, a hotel owned and managed by Defendants Sixty Lower East Side, LLC, Sixty Hotels, LLC, and Sixty Hotel Manager, LLC. Plaintiff has proffered two expert witnesses, Dr. Steven A. Fayer and…
