Category: Expert Challenges
-
Emergency Medicine Expert Barred from Offering Legal Conclusions Regarding whether EMTALA was Violated
The present case stems from incidents occurring around 2:00 a.m. on December 18, 2020, when Angela Cleveland arrived at the Emergency Department (ED) entrance of Bienville Medical Center (BMC) with her 29-year-old son, Kedeldric Dontrez Brown. The Plaintiff has brought claims under the Emergency Medical Treatment and Labor Act (EMTALA), asserting that Brown’s death resulted…
-
Orthopedic Surgery Expert’s Testimony will Assist the Court in Determining Questions of Causation
Following the May 3, 2017 motor vehicle accident that is the basis of this legal action, the Plaintiff presented to the emergency department of Robert Wood Johnson University Hospital with complaints of neck, back, shoulder, and left knee pain. He was then referred to orthopedist Dr. Steven L. Nehmer for evaluation and treatment of his…
-
Ski Safety Expert Fails to Employ Experienced-Based Methodology Properly
On March 19, 2023, a ski collision at Aspen Highlands Ski Resort between Tasha Barber (Plaintiff) and Christine Mack (Defendant) led to a lawsuit. Barber claims Mack, skiing uphill, had the responsibility to avoid the collision and is seeking damages for her resulting injuries. Mack denies these claims and has engaged Jonathan Delk as an…
-
Nursing Expert’s Testimony Would Not Assist the Jury in Determining Whether the Plaintiff has a Disability
Bernice McLaurin has sued her former employer, the Veterans Affairs Medical Center (VAMC) in Jackson, Mississippi, claiming racial discrimination and discrimination based on an unspecified medical disability. McLaurin, an African-American, was hired as a clinical pharmacist at the G.V. Sonny Montgomery Medical Center in Jackson (VAMC) on May 12, 2019, with a one-year probationary period.…
-
Court Accepts the Mortgage Expert’s Opinion on the OPERS’ Primary Fraud Theory
Defendant Federal Home Loan Mortgage Corporation (“Freddie Mac”) offered Dr. Chudozie Okongwu, a mortgage market expert, to discuss the mortgage and subprime markets and the credit crisis between August 1, 2006, and November 20, 2007 (the “Relevant Period”). The lawsuit concerns whether “Freddie Mac concealed its overextension in the nontraditional mortgage market—generally composed of instruments…
-
Engineering Expert’s Testimony on the Formation of Black Ice Admitted
In a premises liability lawsuit, Plaintiff Susana Aqueche claimed she was injured after slipping on ice in the parking lot of a Hobby Lobby and is suing SVAP II Pasadena Crossroads, LLC (SVAP), Sterling Retail, Sterling Mid-Atlantic, The Sterling Organization, Paramount Crossroads, Sterling Organizational Systems, and Hobby Lobby. In response, SVAP, Sterling Retail, Sterling Mid-Atlantic,…
-
Rule 26 Met: Accounting Expert’s Report Provided the Correct Kind of Appendix
Ink 477, LLC and Grove Ink, LLC, operating the Miami restaurant and bar “Amal” and “Level 6,” are accused by former employee Jose Petersen of violating the Fair Labor Standards Act (FLSA). Petersen, who worked as waitstaff at Amal from June to September 2022 and then at Level 6 from May to September 2023, claims…
-
Court Admitted Public Relations Expert’s Testimony Describing the Experience of a Wine Consumer
This case examines the compatibility of Ohio’s three-tier liquor control system, established under the Twenty-first Amendment of the United States Constitution, with the Dormant Commerce Clause. The Sixth Circuit has directed the Court to determine, based on the presented facts and evidence, whether the statutes that Plaintiffs’ challenge “(1) ‘can be justified as a public…
-
Accounting Expert Allowed to Testify Despite Lacking Forensic Accounting Expertise
This case involves a dispute over the alleged misuse of funds from two New Mexico payday lending businesses, Cashco, Inc. and Budget Payday Loans, L.P. The Light Defendants (John Ernest Light, Tina S. Light, and Investors Services, Inc.) were hired to manage the financial operations of these businesses, including record-keeping and transaction processing. They were…
-
Accident Reconstruction Expert Disregards Physical Evidence
William Harrison Sims sustained facial injuries from shrapnel when his BMW’s airbag malfunctioned. He subsequently filed a lawsuit against BMW, claiming negligence and strict product liability. In the legal proceedings, BMW’s accident reconstruction expert, Amanda Duran, P.E., was accused by the Plaintiff of selectively endorsing a defense-favorable theory of the accident without sufficient justification. Defendants…
