Category: Expert Challenges
-
Rejection of Computer Software Expert Witness’ Interpretation Attempt on Contract
This is a breach of contract dispute between Paired Pay and ClearObject. Paired Pay alleged that ClearObject breached the parties’ contract because ClearObject purportedly did not provide a “dedicated” team during a particular phase of the project. Defendant filed a motion to exclude the report and testimony of Larry E. Daniel, one of Plaintiff’s testifying expert witnesses under Federal…
-
Finance Expert Witness’ Art Market Analysis Admitted
Athena, a specialty lender engaged in the business of providing loans secured by high-value fine art, extended a loan to a borrower, using the 1982 painting by Jean-Michel Basquiat titled “Humidity” (the “Basquiat”) as collateral. Subsequently, on March 2, 2020, the New York County Supreme Court entered a judgment for Athena in the amount of…
-
Law Enforcement Expert Witness Testimony on Marijuana Odor Rejected
On July 1, 2020, Officer Jack Gilboy (“Gilboy”) of the St. Charles Parish Sheriff’s Office approached Plaintiff Cedric Otkins (“Otkins”) while Otkins was sitting alone in his parked car at the East Bank Bridge Park in St. Charles Parish, Louisiana. Otkins filed this civil rights action alleging a violation of his Fourth Amendment right to…
-
Testimony of Mechanical Engineering Expert Witness Rejected, Complaint Dismissed
Plaintiff Nathan Cottrill (“Plaintiff” or “Cottrill”) filed a lawsuit against Defendant Tricam Industries, Inc. (“Defendant” or “Tricam”), alleging product liability and breach of implied warranty. Nathan Cottrill, a Best Buy Geek Squad employee, went to a client’s house on December 22, 2019, to mount two Sonos 5 speakers in an indoor basketball court. To carry…
-
Marketing Expert Testimony admitted, case stayed for clarification
Plaintiffs are 31 professional models, actresses, and social media influencers who each earn a living promoting and licensing their image, likeness, and/or identity (collectively, “Image”) to select clients, commercial brands, and media and entertainment outlets, which rely on Plaintiffs to promote, endorse, and sponsor agreed-to goods and services. Plaintiff filed a lawsuit against Orange Lantern,…
-
Economics Expert Witness’ Testimony Rejected on account of Half-Hearted Support for his Methodology
Plaintiffs James and Roxanne Thomas (“Plaintiffs”), on behalf of themselves and all others similarly situated, brought suit against GEICO Casualty Company, GEICO Indemnity Company, and GEICO General Insurance Company (collectively “GEICO” or “Defendants”) for violating the Illinois Consumer Fraud and Deceptive Business Practices Act (“ICFA”). Since 2013, Plaintiffs have been GEICO customers. Plaintiffs renewed their…
-
Biomechanical Engineering Expert Witness’ Testimony As to General Causation of Injuries held to be Permissible
Plaintiff Ernst Nicolas suffered severe injuries to his cervical spine, lumbar spine, right knee, and left shoulder in a motor vehicle accident that took place on September 1st, 2018, on JF Kennedy Blvd at the intersection with 63rd Street, in Jersey City. Nicolas was a rear seat passenger in a Lyft vehicle when a truck…
-
Testimony of Maritime Expert Witness Helps the Court Determine Disputed Facts
On May 5, 2021, Timothy Shannon allegedly sustained personal injuries while he was a passenger aboard M/V MR LLOYD. The vessel traveled from a dock in Fourchon, Louisiana to a Talos Oil & Gas LLC production platform in the Gulf of Mexico. Rodi Marine, LLC owned and operated M/V MR. LLOYD while Talos was the…
-
Testimony of Civil Engineering Expert Witness Admitted despite Alleged Confidential Relationship with Opposing Party
Plaintiffs, Julie Jenkins and James Gunn asserted claims under the Clean Water Act and various Georgia Environmental Statutes, including the Georgia Erosion and Sedimentation Act, arising from wholly past conduct that occurred in 2020. Plaintiffs alleged that “red clay” was deposited on Daniel Bruce’s farmland as part of the farm’s operations and that an unspecified…
-
Marketing Expert Witness’ Survey Estimating the Likelihood of Consumer Confusion Held to be Reliable
Maker’s Mark entered into a Licensing Agreement with Spalding Group gransting an exclusive license to use its trademarks to create and sell cigars seasoned with its bourbon (the “Licensed Cigars”). After renewing the agreement a few times, in 2013, Maker’s Mark notified Spalding that it was terminating the license effective December 31, 2015. Spalding Group…
