Category: Expert Challenges
-
Experts are entitled to a reasonable fee despite objections to the admissibility of their opinions
In February 2016, Plaintiffs-Appellants Scott Miller and Michael Spaulding, two Seattle Police officers, fatally shot Che Andre Taylor, a Black man, as they tried to arrest him. Four days after the shooting, Defendant-Appellee Kshama Sawant, then a member of the Seattle City Council, told a crowd of protestors in front of the Seattle Police Department…
-
Obstetrics and Gynecology Expert Witness’ Testimony About Medical Necessity of Certain Procedures Performed Admitted
In this defamation lawsuit, Plaintiff Mahendra Amin (“Amin”), a doctor, alleged that Defendant Nbcuniversal Media, LLC aired several broadcast segments on MSNBC which included multiple false and defamatory statements about Amin and his medical treatment of detainees at Irwin County Detention Center (ICDC). To support his case, Amin retained Eldridge Bills to review the medical…
-
Mortgage Lending Expert Witness’ Testimony Regarding Deviation from HUD Standards Limited
On November 22, 2019, Plaintiffs Alfredo and Chelsie Dominguez (“collectively “Plaintiffs” or “Dominguez”) refinanced their manufactured home with Wallick & Volk, working with loan originator and W&V employee, Christina Bingham. In February 2020, W&V sold the loan and transferred servicing to The Money Source, Inc. (“TMS”). Nine months later in November 2020, Plaintiffs’ hazard insurance…
-
Automotive Mechanics Expert Witness’ Testimony Rejected Because it is Based Solely on her Experience
On December 31, 2021, Plaintiffs and Defendant entered a Stock Purchase Agreement (SPA) whereby Plaintiffs purchased all the issued and outstanding shares of 411 Flash Corporation (“Company”) from Defendant. Plaintiffs alleged Defendant breached Section 4.09 of the SPA because the repairs made to these vehicles went beyond “ordinary, routine maintenance and repairs” and they were…
-
Financial Expert Witness’ Cash Flow Analysis Admitted
Plaintiff, Yoel Weisshau challenged the constitutionality, under the dormant Commerce Clause, of the Port Authority’s toll and fare increases, in effect since September 18, 2011, on all the Port Authority’s bridges and tunnels within the Interstate Transportation Network (“ITN”). Plaintiff filed a motion to strike Elizabeth McCarthy’s affidavit and cash flow analysis, as well as…
-
Business Valuation Expert Witness’ Financial Projections Admitted
Plaintiff American Northwest Distributors Inc. (“ANW”) was the Washington distributor of Four Roses bourbon, produced by Defendant Four Roses Distillery LLC (“Four Roses”), for about five years from 2015-2020. In 2020, after a pattern of late payments from ANW, Four Roses terminated the distribution agreement and switched to a competitor, Young’s Market Company, LLC (“Young’s…
-
Psychology Expert Witness’ Testimony Assessing Causal Factors Leading up to a Suicide Admitted
This case involved various claims arising from the death of SGT, a minor and former student at St. Marys Middle School in the Camden County School District. Plaintiffs alleged SGT died of suicide because of multiple bullying incidents at the school and Defendants’ failures to adequately respond to and address those incidents and asserted claims under…
-
Law Enforcement Expert Witness’ Testimony About Defendants Deviating from Nationally Accepted Principles Excluded
On May 26, 2020, South Bend police officers began clearing a homeless encampment on city property after prior notice and concerns about crime and COVID-19. Tracy Leliaert, a person with a home who protested the clearing, refused to leave even when warned repeatedly. Officer Joshua Morgan and Officer Ryan Williams eventually arrested her and two…
-
Testimony of Economics Expert Witness Excluded Because of his Inability To Produce a Coherent Model
Plaintiffs brought an antitrust lawsuit against Defendants, asserting that Defendants entered a set of agreements with each other and their broadcast partners that suppressed the output of telecasts of out-of-market professional football games, resulting in higher prices for Sunday Ticket. Since Judge Philip Gutierrez decided the opinions provided by the Plaintiffs’ expert witnesses regarding financial…
-
Orthopedic Surgery Expert Witness’ Opinion on Alleged Personal Orthopedic Injuries Admitted
Plaintiff Rickie Russell, Jr. (“Russell) alleged that, on August 13, 2021, Terry Delmer Prater (“Prater”) crashed an 18-wheeler truck into Russell’s roadside work crew Russell claimed he was pinned between two vehicles and suffered serious injuries as a result of that motor vehicle collision. Russell brought suit against Defendants Prater and Big V Feeds, Inc.…
