Tag: Disclosure
-
Intellectual Property Expert Witness Cannot Cloak her Testimony on Validity with her Experience
EPP and Paveloc both construct and sell “erosion prevention” systems that are used in retaining walls. The systems are made up of interlocking hiocks. EPP has a patent on its “Channel Lock II block” (US Patent No. 8,123,435) (“the 435 patent”). At some point the business relationship soured. Paveloc stopped making the EPP product and began…
-
Late Service of Psychology Expert Witness’ Report Might Cause Severe Prejudice
Plaintiff, Rudolph Mills filed this action against Defendant, Steuben Foods, Inc., alleging employment discrimination based on race after numerous complaints about shocking and wildly inappropriate racial slurs used against him by supervisors and managers. Defendants moved, pursuant to Fed.R.Civ.P. 16(f)(1)(C), 26(a)(2)(A), (D), 37(c)(1)(C), for an order striking the expert report of Mark D. Lerner, PhD.…
-
Accident Reconstruction Expert Barred From Testifying Due to Surprise Opinions
Elmedin Tinjak has been a life-long cyclist. On June 20, 2020, the carbon fiber fork of his brand-new Bianchi bicycle failed, causing him to crash face-first on the pavement. Tinjak was taken to Riverside Methodist Hospital, where he was treated for a concussion, chest contusions, a fractured vertebra, and multiple complex facial lacerations. The injuries…
-
Economics Expert Witness Employs a “Before and After” Methodology to Quantify Plaintiff’s Damages
This action arises out of an alleged October 22, 2016 arrest and subsequent criminal prosecution of Plaintiff, which concluded with Plaintiff’s conviction for misdemeanor battery upon Officer Ermeri. On October 20, 2020, Plaintiff Richard John Lucibella (“Lucibella”) filed a nine-count complaint in state court against Officer Richard Ermeri (“Ermeri”), Officer Savino (“Savino”), and the Town…
-
Criminal Law Expert Witness’ Disclosure Fails to Comply with Rule 16 Requirements with Respect to Three Bullet Points
In a white-collar criminal case where Defendants were charged with conspiracy to commit securities fraud and wire fraud in a pump-and-dump scheme through a publicly traded company, Defendants Paul Spivak and Olga Smirnova filed a motion to exclude the testimony of Peter Melley under Rule 16 of the Federal Rules of Criminal Procedure. Melley is…
-
Insurance Expert Witness’ Testimony About the Industry Norms and Customs of the Insurance Adjustment Process Admitted
This claim arises from 2B’s negligent handing of an auto insurance claim brought by Harold and Milagros Lacey against GoAuto insureds, Alisha and Kayranasia Hill resulting from a motor vehicle accident in Panama City Beach, FL on July 31, 2020 (the “Lacey Claim”). GoAuto is a Louisiana-based insurance company that writes policies in Louisiana, Texas,…
-
Petroleum Engineering Expert Witness’ Testimony Admitted Because his Supplemental Report Does Not Rely on New Information
Plaintiff sued Berry Petroleum Company for injuries incurred while pumping oil for transport as a crude oil truck driver for Savage Industries Inc. In both the initial disclosure and the supplemental disclosure at issue here, Plaintiff designated Edward R. Ziegler as an “oil field, oil tank and oil tank’s ‘thief hatch’ safety expert as to…
-
Law Enforcement Expert Witness’ Supplemental Report on Deviation from Police Practices Admitted
Plaintiff Kevin Strickland filed this lawsuit against the Kansas City, Missouri, Board of Police Commissioners and five Kansas City police officers for alleged unconstitutional conduct that resulted in his wrongful conviction. On June 21, 2024, Plaintiff issued its police practices expert, Russell Fischer’s supplemental report. The supplemental report is 2.5 pages long, and the revisions are…
-
Court refuses to exclude Pharmaceutical Expert Witness’ Opinions Regarding Breadth of Asserted Claims
A district judge in Florida refused to exclude the testimony of a pharmaceutical expert witness despite allegations of fundamental flaws in the assumptions on which her calculations are based. Defendant Aveva Drug Delivery Systems, Inc. of an Abbreviated New Drug Application (“ANDA”) No. 217221 to the U.S. Food and Drug Administration (“FDA”) sought approval to…
-
Accounting Expert Witness’ Analysis of Costs and Markups Admitted
The Trade Group’s (“TTG”) is a full-service event marketing and creative design firm well known for its award-winning designs and client-centered service mentality. BTC Media, LLC (“BTCM”), a Bitcoin and blockchain media company approached TTG about managing, planning, and producing Bitcoin 2021, the world’s largest bitcoin conference held in Miami, Florida. After a successful Bitcoin…
