Tag: Reliable
-
Safety Engineering Expert Allowed to Opine on Codes and Industry Standards
On January 22, 2022, Sharon Marshall was dining at an Outback Steakhouse in Fort Smith, Arkansas, when she slipped, fell, and received serious injuries. She alleged that she slipped on soup that had spilled in the floor which Outback had negligently failed to clean up. Outback has filed motions to exclude or limit the testimony…
-
Audiology Expert’s “Chart Note” is Not a Proper Expert Report
This case stems from a rear-end, chain-reaction accident. Plaintiffs alleged that, on or about June 16, 2019, Plaintiff Miranda Allen was driving northbound on Interstate 5 in Skagit County, Washington, with Plaintiff J.M. as a passenger in her vehicle. While Plaintiff Allen’s vehicle was stopped in traffic, Defendant Martin Barratt, also driving northbound on Interstate…
-
Credit Reporting Expert May Not Opine as to Whether the Procedures were Reasonable or Unreasonable
Plaintiff Barbara Cooper alleged that Defendant Milliman, Inc. (“Milliman”) violated the Fair Credit Reporting Act in two ways: first, whenit issued a report about her medical and prescription history that mixed her with another individual; and second, when it issued a second report wherein Milliman reinserted information it had previously deleted after purportedly reinvestigating Plaintiff’s…
-
Psychology Expert Witness is Unqualified to Testify as to Reputational Damages
On June 15, 2020, Michael J. Fitzgerald and Ronda and Will McNae finalized a Settlement Agreement to resolve claims related to alleged rape and sexual assault. This agreement included Fitzgerald paying a sum of money and, in return, the McNaes releasing their claims, agreeing not to contact Fitzgerald’s employer, SoftwareONE, refrain from writing about him…
-
Recreational Vehicle Expert’s Valuation Determination Complies with Rule 702
Plaintiff Jason Greene purchased a recreational vehicle (“RV”) from Defendant Thor Motor Coach, Inc. (“Thor”). The purchase included a 12 month / 15,000 mile limited warranty (the “Limited Warranty”). After purchasing the RV, Greene encountered issues with the RV that led him to seek repairs on several occasions. Some issues remained even after the attempted…
-
Data Privacy Expert Has Sufficient Experience in TCPA Compliance and Wrong Number Issues
David Elliot filed a lawsuit against Humana, claiming the company violated the Telephone Consumer Protection Act (TCPA) by repeatedly calling him with robocalls even though he wasn’t a customer and had informed them they had the wrong number. Elliot wants to pursue this as a class action, arguing that many others have experienced similar unwanted…
-
Court Accepts the Mortgage Expert’s Opinion on the OPERS’ Primary Fraud Theory
Defendant Federal Home Loan Mortgage Corporation (“Freddie Mac”) offered Dr. Chudozie Okongwu, a mortgage market expert, to discuss the mortgage and subprime markets and the credit crisis between August 1, 2006, and November 20, 2007 (the “Relevant Period”). The lawsuit concerns whether “Freddie Mac concealed its overextension in the nontraditional mortgage market—generally composed of instruments…
-
Engineering Expert’s Testimony on the Formation of Black Ice Admitted
In a premises liability lawsuit, Plaintiff Susana Aqueche claimed she was injured after slipping on ice in the parking lot of a Hobby Lobby and is suing SVAP II Pasadena Crossroads, LLC (SVAP), Sterling Retail, Sterling Mid-Atlantic, The Sterling Organization, Paramount Crossroads, Sterling Organizational Systems, and Hobby Lobby. In response, SVAP, Sterling Retail, Sterling Mid-Atlantic,…
-
Court Admitted Public Relations Expert’s Testimony Describing the Experience of a Wine Consumer
This case examines the compatibility of Ohio’s three-tier liquor control system, established under the Twenty-first Amendment of the United States Constitution, with the Dormant Commerce Clause. The Sixth Circuit has directed the Court to determine, based on the presented facts and evidence, whether the statutes that Plaintiffs’ challenge “(1) ‘can be justified as a public…
-
Accounting Expert Allowed to Testify Despite Lacking Forensic Accounting Expertise
This case involves a dispute over the alleged misuse of funds from two New Mexico payday lending businesses, Cashco, Inc. and Budget Payday Loans, L.P. The Light Defendants (John Ernest Light, Tina S. Light, and Investors Services, Inc.) were hired to manage the financial operations of these businesses, including record-keeping and transaction processing. They were…
