Tag: Supplemental
-
Rule 26 Violation is Harmless with Regard to the Engineering Expert’s Repair Estimates
In this insurance breach of contract case, Plaintiff LJP Building, LLC designated Alfredo Brizuela as its damages expert in March 2024. That same month, Brizuela prepared an estimate to restore the property to its pre-loss condition. The estimate was based on replacement cost value (RCV) and totaled $655,054.64. Westchester deposed Brizuela in February 2025. Subsequent…
-
Materials Science Expert’s Supplemental Report Excluded Despite a Compelling Explanation for the Tardiness
This is an insurance coverage dispute. Defendant Church Mutual Insurance Company (“Church Mutual”) insured Plaintiffs’ property. Hail damaged the property’s roof. The parties dispute whether the damage falls within Plaintiffs’ insurance policy, which precludes coverage for cosmetic damage. Plaintiffs sought to exclude the expert testimony of Christine Conner, Mark Kubena, and Ronald Dutton on the…
-
Court Rejects Anesthesiology Expert’s Testimony Over Incomplete Medical Evidence
In a recent case involving a police shooting in Las Cruces, the admissibility of expert testimony became a central point of contention. The Plaintiff, who sustained injuries during the incident, sought to introduce Dr. Alen Ternian as a pain management expert. However, the Defendants challenged Ternian’s testimony, raising significant concerns about the completeness and reliability…
-
Insurance Expert Witness’ Estimate Excluded Because Unknown Contractors Collected the Data
Plaintiffs Gregory Hebbler and Marion Hebbler contracted with Defendant State Farm Fire and Casualty Company to insure their home located at 6009 Angler Drive, Picayune, Mississippi. On August 29, 2021, Hurricane Ida made landfall, purportedly damaging the residence. When Defendant conducted an on-site inspection and estimated the monetary damage caused by Hurricane Ida, it issued…