Category: Insurance Expert Witness
-
The Insurance Expert’s Testimony on Claims Handling Contained Deficiencies
This is an insurance coverage dispute arising from a car accident between Plaintiffs, in which Plaintiffs seek to enforce a liability insurance policy issued by Defendant to Plaintiff Anita Myers that was later assigned to Plaintiff Sarah Montalvan. Defendant sought to exclude the testimony of Peter Knowe, Plaintiffs’ designated insurance claims handling expert while Plaintiffs…
-
Insurance Expert Allowed to Opine on Sales Tax Depreciation Practices
Plaintiffs Melissa Pitkin and Dan Grout own a home together in Healdsburg, California. They hold a homeowner’s insurance policy from State Farm, policy number 57-C4-6752-1 (the “Policy”), which covered certain losses to their home and all of its contents. The Policy included the “main policy form” (FP-7955, CA) as well as a “homeowners endorsement form”…
-
Neurology Expert Was Not Allowed to Opine on Credibility of Other Witnesses
This civil action arises from a motor vehicle accident involving Plaintiff Sarah Kollman on February 20, 2019. The other driver, Taylor Bonello, was at-fault for the collision, which Plaintiff alleged caused her physical injuries. At the time of the collision, Bonello was insured for liability with Progressive Insurance company for $100,000.000. Plaintiff had an underinsured…
-
Real Estate Expert Not Allowed to Opine on Undue Hardship
On September 24, 2024, Plaintiff Pharilyn Chhang filed the operative second amended complaint against Defendants West Coast and Sergio Madrigal, alleging causes of action under the Fair Housing Act (FHA), California Fair Employment and Housing Act (FEHA), wrongful eviction; invasion of private right to occupancy; and breach of duty. Plaintiff claimed that she is a disabled…
-
Insurance Expert Not Allowed to Opine on the Actual Cash Value of the Home
On November 10, 2022, Kenneth and Phyllis Zerr perished in a house fire. Plaintiffs—the Zerrs’ children and Kenneth Zerr’s estate—alleged that the fire was caused by a defective dehumidifier produced by Gree. Defendants sought to call an insurance adjuster, Steven Weitz, to testify as to the value of the home, and its contents, before and…
-
Roofing Expert’s Causation Opinion Excluded
This case arises out of an insurance claim (the “Claim”) Plaintiff Mike Nguyen submitted to Allstate seeking coverage under his homeowners insurance policy (the “Policy”) for damages to the roof and certain exterior components of his dwelling (the “Property”) that he said were caused by a hail storm that occurred on May 1, 2022 (the…
-
Accounting Expert Was Not Allowed to Opine on Damages to Uninsureds
This case centers on a landslide that occurred in May 2017 in the Cincinnati neighborhood of Mount Adams. At the time of the landslide, Plaintiff Metropolitan Design & Development, LLC (“MDD”) was insured under a commercial liability policy with Defendant Frankenmuth Mutual Insurance Company (“Frankenmuth”). MDD performed construction work in the vicinity of the landslide…
-
Insurance Expert Not Allowed to Opine on Legal Duties
Plaintiff Lorenzo Garcia alleged that he was lawfully stopped at a red light when the vehicle Kenneth Childress was driving collided with the vehicle Pasty Ration was driving, causing Ms. Ration’s vehicle to strike the rear of Garcias vehicle. Garcia further alleged that as a result of the accident he sustained permanent, disabling injuries requiring…
-
Insurance Expert Not Allowed to Opine on the Cause of Death
Plaintiffs are the estate and heirs of Timothy Hunt, who was killed in a grain engulfment accident. Defendant is the insurance company who insured the farm (Butts Farms) where the accident occurred. Defendant denied coverage for the accident under the policy. Butts Farms assigned its claims to Plaintiffs as part of an arbitration and non-execution…
-
Insurance Expert Not Allowed to Opine on Industry Standards
This action arises from an insurance claim related to a vehicle fire that occurred on May 31, 2024, in Arkansas while Plaintiff Anthony Nicholas was driving from Tennessee to Oklahoma. Plaintiff submitted a claim to Defendant Progressive Direct Insurance Company that same day. Plaintiff alleged that Defendant failed to handle the claim in good faith…
