Category: Expert Challenges
-
Finance Expert Allowed to Opine on Loss Causation
Stadium Capital (“Stadium”), the Lead Plaintiff in this class action lawsuit, has sued Co-Diagnostics (“CoDx”), its CEO Dwight Egan, and its CFO Brian Brown, for allegedly making false or misleading statements in violation of the Securities Exchange Act of 1934. Defendants filed a motion to exclude the testimony of Stadium’s expert witness, Chad W. Coffman…
-
Orthopedic Surgery Expert’s Testimony on Physical Injuries Excluded
The instant matter arises out of a power catamaran scenic and snorkel tour that Plaintiffs Candice Myhre and Norman Davidson, IV boarded on May 14, 2021 from Kikiaola Small Boat Harbor. As the vessel began to exit the harbor, it encountered large waves, and Myhre stated that she flew out of her seat, hit her…
-
Logistics Expert’s Fraud-Related Opinions Excluded
This is a False Claims Act action arising from Defendants Fluor Corporation, Inc. and Fluor Intercontinental, Inc.’s (“Fluor”) performance of logistics and life-support services for the United States military in Afghanistan under the Logistics Civil Augmentation Program IV (“LOGCAP IV”) contract and Task Order 0005 (“TO5”). Relators alleged, among other things, that Fluor knowingly submitted…
-
Law And Legal Expert’s Testimony on OPDA’s Practices Admitted
This litigation arises from Plaintiff Raymond Flanks’ (“Plaintiff”) wrongful conviction for first-degree murder in 1985. In particular, Plaintiff alleged that the Orleans Parish District Attorney’s Office (“OPDA”) secured his wrongful conviction in violation of his constitutional rights by withholding material exculpatory evidence. Laurie Levenson is a law professor who was retained by Plaintiff to testify…
-
Law And Legal Expert Was Barred From Opining on the Trust Agreement
The Plaintiff, Christopher Ayash, is a named beneficiary of the Patricia Louise Ayash Living Trust (“Trust”), created by his late mother (“Grantor”) in 2002. The Trust also named two of the Grantor’s other sons as beneficiaries. The Defendants, David Barnette and Karl Hamm, serve as Trustees. The Trustees are directed to divide and hold the…
-
Materials Science Expert’s Testimony on Fire Causation Excluded
Ibrahim Qasim bought a sixty-four ounce container of EcoLogic Bed Bug Killer 2 (“Product”) from Home Depot on August 26, 2019. On September 2, 2019, at 9:00 a.m., Ibrahim sprayed all sixty-four ounces of the product into the living room of the apartment he and Nouh Qasim shared. At 5:00 p.m., as Nouh turned on…
-
Insurance Expert Was Allowed to Opine on Damage Causation
This case involves allegations of underpayment and nonpayment under an insurance policy. Ategrity Specialty Insurance Company issued Policy No. 01-C-PK-P20064154-0 to 707 FWY Investments, LLC with effective dates of September 12, 2022, to September 12, 2023. Plaintiff leased out this structure to commercial tenants. The roof collapsed and then several severe rain and windstorms allowed…
-
Mechanical Engineering Expert Allowed to Opine on Tile Flooring
This matter arises out of a slip and fall incident that occurred in the restroom at the Waffle House restaurant in Dillon, South Carolina. On January 3, 2020, Plaintiff Loretta Diaz entered the ladies’ restroom at the Defendants’ Waffle House location and traversed the restroom floor, when she slipped and fell on a foreign substance…
-
Life Care Planning Expert’s Testimony on Future Care Limited
On October 27, 2022, a three-vehicle collision occurred on Interstate-10 in Phoenix, Arizona. Defendant Eduardo Serrato was operating a tractor trailer when he struck the rear of a Dodge Dart, killing a non-party individual inside the vehicle. The Dodge Dart was pushed across two lanes, and it impacted the tractor trailer containing Plaintiffs Robert Hanifon…
-
Actuarial Science Expert Was Allowed to Opine on the Resulting Damage
This action arises from a dispute about the payment of service fees by Bulldog National Risk Retention Group (“Bulldog”) to Plaintiff GB Group. Specifically, the dispute centers on a Service Agreement between GB Group and Bulldog, as well as an Addendum thereto entered into in July 2018 and August 2020. To begin with, GB Group…
