Category: Expert Challenges
-
Nursing Expert Witness’ Opinion Addressing Medical Causation Excluded
Plaintiff, Prunella Banks filed this medical negligence action against Lakeland Nursing and Rehabilitation Center, LLC (“Lakeland”) and one of its nurses, Morgan McGuire, for injuries allegedly suffered by her late mother, Queen Banks during her short residency at the nursing home from April 21, 2021, to May 3, 2021. According to the Complaint, Nurse McGuire…
-
Opinions of the Geology Expert Witness Regarding Copying of the Patented Technology Excluded
This case involves an alleged breach of a non-disclosure agreement (the NDA) and patent infringement stemming from the management, construction, and operation of a large lagoon in St. George, Utah (the Lagoon) by Defendants, Desert Color Manager, LLC, Desert Color St. George, LLC, and Pacific Aquascape International, Inc. Specifically, Plaintiffs Crystal Lagoons U.S. Corp. and…
-
Court Excludes Data Analysis Expert Witness’ Opinions on the Issue of Fair Housing
Plaintiff, the Fair Housing Center of Central Indiana (“FHCCI”) sued Defendants, M&J Management Company, LLC, d/b/a The Sexton Companies, Sexton Carlyle, LLC, Remington Court, LLC, and Sexton Windsor, LLC (collectively, the “Defendants” or “M&J Management”) based solely on Defendants’ occupancy policy requiring no more than two occupants per bedroom (“Defendants’ Occupancy Standard”). FHCCI claimed Defendants’…
-
Structural Engineering Expert Witness’ Testimony on the Age and Cause of the Damage to the Roof Admitted
This is a removed action by Plaintiff Wings Platinum LLC , an insured, against its insurer, Defendant Westchester Surplus Lines Insurance Company, arising from the denial of Wings’ claim for coverage following a wind and hail storm. Wings asserted claims for breach of contract; unfair settlement practices, and breach of the duty of good faith and…
-
Law And Legal Expert Witness Cannot Opine on the Standard of Care of Non-Lawyers
Joy Banner brought this suit against Defendants Michael Wright, St. John the Baptist Parish, and Jaclyn Hotard (collectively “Defendants”) alleging violations of her First Amendment right to freedom of speech during a St. John the Baptist Parish council meeting. Richard Stanley, an attorney-expert, has been hired by Defendants to opine about “whether a person could…
-
Insurance Adjuster Expert Witness’ Testimony Admitted Despite Methodological Deficiencies in Gathering Prices
Plaintiff Ram Krishana Inc., a Louisiana business owned by Mukesh and Kailash Zaveri, operated as Motel 6 (“Hotel Property”) at 2022 Ruth Street, Sulphur, Louisiana. ANK Holdings, LLC, a Louisiana limited liability company with the same Mukesh and Kailash Zaveri as its only members, owned a restaurant (“Restaurant Property”) at an adjoining address. Defendant Mt.…
-
Safety Expert Witness’ Lack of Consideration of Certain Documents did not Render his Opinion Unreliable
This lawsuit arises out of the designation of Sassine Avenue as a “no truck route.” Plaintiff, Kirk Thomas, engages in various agricultural and commercial pursuits, many of which involve the use of his property. Consequently, commercial vehicles commonly travel to and from Thomas’s property. Plaintiffs Thomas and KT Trucking and Cattle, LLC, asserted that the only safe…
-
Law And Legal Expert Witness Improperly Speculates about the Defendant’s Motivation
This is an insurance bad faith case stemming from Westfield’s handling of a first-party property insurance claim following a fire. Plaintiffs JME Investments, LLC (“JME”) and Hiway Bar, LLC (“Hiway Bar”) (together, “Plaintiffs”) filed claims after a kitchen fire damaged their property on July 12, 2020. The fire burned a building owned by JME. Constructed…
-
Risk Management Expert Witness’ Testimony on Economic Injury Conditionally Admitted
In June 2008, USA experienced the collapse of the housing market and the worst financial crisis since the Great Depression. For homeowners who put down less than 20% for the purchase of their homes, most were required to purchase private mortgage insurance to protect their lenders in the event of default. Many of those private…
-
Elevator and Escalator Expert Witness’ Testimony on Elevator Malfunction Admitted
In September 2019, Plaintiff Nathan White, a security guard at the Cosmopolitan Hotel in Las Vegas, inhaled fumes from a malfunctioning elevator while responding to a smoke alarm in the elevator’s brake room. Days later, Defendant TKE’s (formerly known as Thyssenkrupp Elevator) employees recklessly destroyed the relevant elevator parts. Plaintiff sued Defendant TKE under strict products…
