Tag: Causation
-
Neurosurgery Expert Witness’ Causation Testimony Regarding Elbow Infection Excluded
On March 19, 2018, Ralph Monte (“Monte”) visited the Defendant Sherwin-Williams Development Corporation’s store at 4473 South Semoran Boulevard in Orlando, Florida. While attempting to negotiate the ramp from the parking lot to the sidewalk, a wheelchair-bound Monte fell and sustained injuries. He claimed that the fall occurred because Defendant negligently maintained the premises and/or…
-
Neurology Expert Witness’ Injury Causation Testimony Admitted
Plaintiff, William Harrison Sims’ claims arise out of an October 24, 2019, two-vehicle collision involving Plaintiff, who was operating the 2004 BMW (“Subject BMW”). Tameca Harris-Jackson (“HarrisJackson”) was operating the Hyundai that collided with the Subject BMW. Plaintiff alleges he sustained “severe, permanent, and life-altering injuries” due to the driver-side Takata airbag unexpectedly rupturing and…
-
Adjuster Expert Witness’ Licensure Qualifies Him to Testify About Damage Causation
This case involves a Hurricane Laura claim by Plaintiff Rapides Station Land Company, LLC (“Plaintiff”), the owner of the property known as “Cowboy Town” located in Boyce, Louisiana, near Interstate 49, for alleged property damage attributable to the Hurricane. Markel American Insurance Company (“MAIC”) issued a builders risk policy of insurance to Plaintiff which provided…
-
Court Admits Pediatrics Expert Witness’ Specific Causation Opinion Based on Differential Diagnosis
For over 10 years, Fisher-Price sold a product called the Rock ‘n Play Sleeper (RnP). The Plaintiff, Ameena Brown, argued that the defective design of the RnP was to blame because her infant son, A.B., had died from sleeping in it. The dangers of this inclined sleeper product were widely debated in this case. It…
-
Testimony of the Biomechanical Engineering Expert Witness About the Dangers of Inclined Sleepers Limited
For over 10 years, Fisher-Price sold a product called the Rock ‘n Play Sleeper (RnP). The Plaintiff, Ameena Brown, argued that the defective design of the RnP was to blame because her infant son, A.B., had died from sleeping in it. The dangers of this inclined sleeper product were widely debated in this case. It…
-
Insurance Expert Witness’ Estimate Excluded Because Unknown Contractors Collected the Data
Plaintiffs Gregory Hebbler and Marion Hebbler contracted with Defendant State Farm Fire and Casualty Company to insure their home located at 6009 Angler Drive, Picayune, Mississippi. On August 29, 2021, Hurricane Ida made landfall, purportedly damaging the residence. When Defendant conducted an on-site inspection and estimated the monetary damage caused by Hurricane Ida, it issued…
-
Occupational Medicine Expert Witness’ Testimony As to the Causation of the Subject Incident Admitted
This lawsuit involves an alleged slip and fall in the Petco Store. Plaintiff, Lisa Brune alleged multiple injuries caused by the slip and fall and sought damages for same. Plaintiff complained that Petco failed to adhere to this Court’s Order. Then Plaintiff complained that the testimonies, opinions, and/or reports of David C. Randolph, M.D., Ph.D., and…
-
Firearms & Ballistics Expert Witness’ Testimony About the Unintentional Discharge Excluded
Plaintiff Michael Colwell alleged that a Sig Sauer P320, which he was issued in connection with his duties as a police officer in Troy, New York, discharged during a police training exercise even though Plaintiff never touched the trigger. Plaintiff testified that he put the gun in his holster during the exercise and was starting…
-
Building and Construction Expert Witness’ Hurricane Damage Assessment Does Not Warrant Exclusion
It all started when Hurricanes Laura and Delta inflicted significant damage on Plaintiffs’ rental property on August 27, 2020, and October 9, 2020, respectively. Southern Fidelity Insurance Company (SFIC) insured the property at the time of the damage. However, SFIC subsequently declared bankruptcy, and the Louisiana Insurance Guaranty Association (“LIGA”) has since been substituted as…
-
Fraud Examination Expert Witness’ Testimony About the Effect of Misappropriated Trade Secrets Excluded
This case stems from a trade secret dispute between University of Mississippi Medical Center (“UMMC”) and Defendant Dr. Spencer Sullivan, a former employee of UMMC. The Court has resolved the issue of liability through its Order granting default judgment in favor of Plaintiff. The injury pleaded by UMMC is the loss of certain specific former…
