Tag: Causation
-
Biomechanics Expert’s Testimony on Law Enforcement Tactics Excluded
Plaintiffs alleged that Defendants former Washington County Sheriff’s Office (“WCSO”) Deputy Defendant Jeffrey Aaron Edwards (“Edwards” or “Deputy Edwards”) and former WCSO Deputy Brian Mizelle (“Mizelle” or “Deputy Mizelle”) used excessive force against them during a March 2, 2022, attempt to transport Plaintiff Gary Thomas (“Thomas”) to the Washington County Courthouse. The factual circumstances in…
-
Expert Testimony on Driver Hiring and Retention Practices Admitted
In July 2019, Plaintiff Amy Kessler was driving her car on Interstate 90 when she was rear-ended by a semitruck owned by Defendant McFarland Truck Lines, Inc. that, at the time, was being operated by Defendant Archie Gross within the scope of his employment with McFarland. As a result of the injuries she sustained in…
-
Orthopedic Surgery Expert’s Testimony on Knee Injury Admitted
Plaintiff Maria Marano slipped and fell while at a Sam’s Club store. She subsequently filed a negligence lawsuit against Defendant Sam’s East, Inc., alleging that she sustained a meniscal tear in her knee as a result of the fall. Defendant disputes whether there is a causal connection between the fall and injury. Marano offered Dr.…
-
Family Medicine Expert’s Standard-of-Care Testimony Excluded
This lawsuit arises out of medical care and treatment Courtney L. Mapes rendered to Plaintiff Bradley Medina on February 8, 2019 at Family Health Care Network. Medina brought a cause of action against Mapes for medical negligence based on the allegation that Mapes misdiagnosed him with a hamstring injury rather than an infection in his leg.…
-
Obstetrics Expert’s Testimony on Brain Damage Limited
Elizabeth Reyes and her minor daughter G.T. sued the United States, Bronx Lebanon Hospital Center, BronxCare Health System, and two doctors over G.T.’s permanent medical conditions, which the Plaintiffs alleged were caused by mistakes made during Reyes’ labor and delivery and G.T.’s neonatal care. The Bronx Lebanon Defendants filed a motion to preclude Plaintiffs’ obstetrics…
-
Psychiatry Experts’ Opinions on Causation and Permanency Admitted
This action arises from the pled sexual assault of Plaintiff Margaret Betts by a massage therapist during an in-room massage appointment at Sixty LES, a hotel owned and managed by Defendants Sixty Lower East Side, LLC, Sixty Hotels, LLC, and Sixty Hotel Manager, LLC. Plaintiff has proffered two expert witnesses, Dr. Steven A. Fayer and…
-
Mechanical Engineering Expert’s Opinions on the Shattered French Press Limited
Plaintiff, Wade Mullen, filed a products liability lawsuit against Defendant Bodum USA, Inc. (“Bodum”), claiming damages for injuries he suffered when his Bodum French press shattered and splashed him with hot coffee. Bodum filed a motion to exclude the testimony of Mullen’s expert Mingxi Zheng, an engineer who inspected the shattered French press. Mechanical Engineering…
-
Biomechanics Expert’s Subjective Assurances do not Establish Admissibility
This case arises from a January 2023 automobile accident. On April 16, 2023, Plaintiff Gina Martin was driving eastbound on Interstate I-10, nearing the Chef Menteur exit in New Orleans, Louisiana, when Defendant Micah Cunningham crashed his truck into the rear of Martin’s vehicle. Martin alleged that she suffered various severe injuries as a result…
-
Architecture Expert’s Opinions on Causation and Damages Admitted
Plaintiffs Michael Gerstman and Marie Webster, the insureds, sued Defendant Crestbrook Insurance Company (“Crestbrook”), their insurer, to recover on contractual and extracontractual theories arising from Crestbrook’s denial of their claim in this storm damage insurance coverage dispute. Crestbrook filed a motion to strike the testimony of Plaintiffs’ experts, Dr. Neil Hall and Kevin Funsch. Architecture…
-
Orthopedic Surgery Expert’s Opinions About an Aggravation of Pre-Existing Degenerative Disc Disease Admitted
Plaintiff Myles Childress brought his claims against Defendant Wal-Mart Stores East I, LP. after he allegedly sustained injuries while delivering goods to a Walmart store in Bridgeton, Missouri. Plaintiff raised claims against both Defendant Walmart and Walmart’s employee, an unknown Doe Defendant. Dr. Richard Kube is an orthopedic spine surgeon practicing in Peoria, Illinois. Defendant argued…