Tag: Daubert
-
Appraisal and Valuation Expert is Qualified to Testify about the Value of the Porsche
Joseph Falasco bought a non-functioning 1974 Porsche 911S for $10,000 and put a significant amount of time and money into restoring it, including the installation of a new engine and transmission. Falasco later filed a claim regarding the non-collision fire that destroyed Plaintiff’s 1974 Porsche 911S (the “1974 Porsche”) and ended up suing USAA for…
-
Accounting Expert’s Opinion Concerning Labor Costs Excluded
This case arises out of Delta’s delayed donut wrapping system. In late 2021, Bon Appetit Danish, Inc. and Bon Appetit Specialty Snacks, LLC (collectively, “Bon Appetit”) and Delta Systems and Automation, LLC’s (“Delta”) entered into a set of three contracts for Delta to manufacture packaging systems for Bon Appetit’s baked goods. But the donut packaging…
-
Urology Expert’s Opinion on Reusing Single-Use Catheters Admitted
Plaintiffs are the wheelchair-bound current or former inmates of the New York State Department of Corrections and Community Supervision (“DOCCS”) who must self-catheterize themselves multiple times per day in order to urinate. Plaintiffs claimed that they experienced violation of their federal civil rights, and discrimination on the basis of their disabilities. Urologist Ezekiel Young, M.D.,…
-
Engineering Expert Qualified to Opine on Crossbow Malfunction
Scott and Melanie Campbell (“Plaintiffs”) brought this case against Ravin Crossbows, LLC and Velocity Outdoor Inc. (collectively, “Defendants”). This case arises from personal injuries sustained by Plaintiff Scott Campbell (“Scott”), an experienced hunter. On November 9, 2022, Scott was hunting from a ladder stand using a Ravin 10 Crossbow, manufactured by Ravin Crossbows. He attempted…
-
Physical Medicine & Rehabilitation Expert’s Opinion as to the Permanency of Injuries Excluded
Plaintiff Manuel G. Milan commenced this action against New Jersey Transit Rail Operations, Inc. seeking damages for injuries sustained to his ankle and low back under the Federal Employers’ Liability Act. Defendant challenged the expert medical opinions of Dr. Aaron Bellew, DPM and Dr. Jason Smith, M.D. Bellew and Smith offered testimony as to the Plaintiff’s…
-
Transportation Engineering Expert Witness’ Opinion on Routine Commerce Deemed Reliable
This lawsuit arises out of Port Arthur’s decision to designate Sassine Avenue as a “no truck route.” Kirk Thomas (“Thomas”) and KT Trucking and Cattle, LLC (“KT Trucking”) (collectively, “Plaintiffs”) engaged in various agricultural and commercial activities on Thomas’ property, including a land farming operation and the management of his personal trucking business. As a…
-
Pain Management Expert Witness Overstepped by Offering Opinions on Fraud
In a civil RICO lawsuit, Plaintiff Allstate Insurance and its affiliates sued Defendants Dr. Ayman Tarabishy and his medical clinic, Ayman Tarabishy, M.D., PLLC, (doing business as Enhance Center). Allstate alleged that the Defendants orchestrated a racketeering scheme to exploit Michigan’s no-fault insurance law by generating and submitting fraudulent medical bills for reimbursement. Allstate retained…
-
Architecture Expert Witness Barred from Testifying About Slope and Cross-Slope Because His Opinions Were Not Timely Disclosed
On March 19, 2018, Ralph Monte (“Monte”) visited the Defendant Sherwin-Williams Development Corporation’s store at 4473 South Semoran Boulevard in Orlando, Florida. While attempting to negotiate the ramp from the parking lot to the sidewalk, a wheelchair-bound Monte fell and sustained injuries. He claimed that the fall occurred because Defendant negligently maintained the premises and/or…
-
Court Admits Economics Expert Witness’ Analysis of Plaintiff’s Postinjury Economic Capacity in the Absence of the Incident
The present lawsuit involves a tort dispute arising from an incident in which Andrés González-Pérez (“Plaintiff” or “González”) was allegedly injured after he fell from a poorly maintained ladder that provided access to a vessel owned and operated by Harley Marine Financing LLC (“HMF”) and Harley Marine NY, Inc. (“HMNY,” collectively “Defendants” or “Harley Marine”).…
-
Radiology Expert Witness’ Testimony Admitted Despite Claims of Being Cumulative
On November 18, 2021, Plaintiff was driving his vehicle on LA 21 in St. Tammany, Louisiana, when he alleged that Reginald Mitchell (Defendant), attempted to merge into the left lane while operating a tractor-trailer, causing a collision. As a result of this collision, Plaintiff sustained injuries. Defendants retained Dr. Ryan T. Fitzgerald, a radiologist, and Dr. Everett G.…
