Tag: methodology
-
Class Size Calculations of Economics Expert Witness Held to be Reliable
Spokeo owns and operates the website spokeo.com. It collects consumer and public data from various public sources and private vendors, associates that data with particular names, and publishes it online. Using proprietary algorithms and systems, Spokeo “attempts to collect and aggregate and merge all that data into persons, person objects, which are then designated with…
-
Business Valuation Expert Witness’ Assessment of Whether the CFO’s Actions Conformed with the Standard Conduct Rejected
A district judge in Florida limited the testimony of a Business Valuation Expert Witness because he did not identify how exactly the CFO breached his unidentified standard of care. This case arises out of Nextplat’s termination of its former Chief Financial Officer (“CFO”), Thomas Seifert. Nextplat contended in its Second Amended Complaint (among other things)…
-
Insurance Expert Witness’ Opinions about California Claims Handling Practices Rejected
Plaintiff Oxnard Manor LP dba Oxnard Manor Health Center (“Plaintiff”) is a skilled nursing facility. As relevant herein, Defendant Hallmark Specialty Insurance Company (“Defendant”) issued a liability insurance policy to Plaintiff effective from June 1, 2017, to June 1, 2018. Defendant then issued a second liability insurance policy effective June 1, 2018, to June 1, 2019.…
-
Epidemiology Expert Witness’ General Causation Opinion Rejected
This is a multidistrict litigation (“MDL”) in which over 5,000 individual Plaintiffs allege that they developed Parkinson’s disease because of their exposure to an herbicide, paraquat dichloride (“paraquat”). Paraquat is a restricted-use quaternary ammonium herbicide that is used to control weeds in farming operations and other settings around the United States. Defendants, Syngenta Crop Protection, LLC…
-
Life Care Planning Expert Witness Deemed Qualified to Diagnose Plaintiff’s Injuries
A district judge in Missouri allowed a emergency room physician, who also happens to be a certified life care planner, to diagnose the Plaintiff’s injuries and attribute them to the vehicle accident at issue. This matter arises from a January 2021 vehicular collision. A United States Postal Service (“USPS”) employee, driving a delivery truck, rear-ended a…
-
Trade Secrets Expert Witness’ Testimony Based on his own Experience Admitted
A district judge in Texas admitted the testimony of a trade secrets expert witness, taking into consideration his extensive and specialized experience. Plaintiff BHI, a leader in the energy industry providing project management and staffing support to the nuclear, fossil, wind, hydro, and government energy markets accused the Defendants KVP Energy Services, Dustin Coble, Welborn…
-
Accounting Expert Witness’ Opinions on Due Diligence Procedures Admitted
A district judge in Mississippi held that the accounting expert witness was more than qualified to testify about the due diligence requirements in the stock purchase agreement in question. Facts of the case: Casey Morgan (“Morgan”) and Jimmy Ward (“Ward”) (collectively “Plaintiffs”) previously owned and operated Bigfoot Land Services, Inc. (“Bigfoot” or “the company”), an…
-
Architecture Expert Witness Fails to Establish the Reliability of his Stability Testing Methodology
A district judge in Louisiana limited the testimony of a renowned architect, citing a complete failure to explain the origin of his methodology or to point to scientific support for the technique that reliably predicts the likelihood that a canopy on display in a store is dangerous, despite his years of experience. To begin with,…
-
Pathology Expert Witness’ Testimony Excluded Due to Rampant Plagiarism
A district judge barred Harvard pathologist from testifying because his report was merely a wholesale adoption of International Agency for Research on Cancer’s (“IARC”) findings under the guise of his own expertise. In this toxic tort case that is part of a suite of companion cases, more than sixty Plaintiffs allege that Defendant Lockheed Martin…
-
Premises Liability Expert Witness’ Testimony Limited due to being based on Observable Contents
In May 2021, Plaintiff Drew Krantz visited Adrien Crastes’ apartment at Lewisburg in Pennsylvania. The Defendant, Market Street Investment Corporation, Inc owned the premises. Krantz and others decided to install a window air conditioning unit in Crastes’ window. But when Krantz tried to open the window, the windowpane broke and fell on his wrist, causing the injury…
