Tag: Reliable
-
Life Care Planning Expert’s Testimony on Future Medical Care Needs Admitted
A July 2022 vehicle collision in Gallup, New Mexico, triggered a lawsuit claiming severe injuries. Plaintiff Jimmy Woodall claimed that DefendantCurt Moeller made an “unsafe lane change,” forcing his tractor-trailer into a guardrail. Woodall alleged that the crash caused him “severe and disabling injuries.” Woodall sued the Defendants, demanding medical expenses along with damages for…
-
Neurology Expert’s Opinions on Medical Causation Are Not Outside the Scope of His Expertise
This civil rights action stems from the in-custody death of Kimberley Morrissey-Scalia while a pretrial detainee in Lerdo Pre-Trial Facility in Kern County. Plaintiffs filed a motion to preclude Defendants’ expert, Michael E. Gold, M.D., “from: (1) testifying to any opinions on medical causation that are outside the scope of his expertise; and (2) testifying…
-
Intellectual Property Expert’s Opinion as to a Safer Design for a Splitting Maul Admitted
Plaintiff, Joseph Ferlito purchased a splitting maul (an axe specially designed for splitting wood) from Defendant, Harbor Freight Tools USA, Inc. in 2017. Several months later, while the Plaintiff was hanging the maul to store it, the head of the tool detached and struck Plaintiff, causing injuries to his nose and left eye. Plaintiff initiated…
-
Engineering Expert’s Opinion on Cost Estimates Admitted
The Great Lakes Insurance Company issued a policy of insurance (the “Policy”) to Gulf Coast Bank and Trust (“Gulf Coast”) covering specific buildings owned by BRH Consultants, specifically, the Burbank Landing Apartments. Subsequently, BRH alleged that on August 29, 2021, Hurricane Ida caused damage to Buildings 1 and 2 of the property. Following this event,…
-
Safety Engineering Expert Allowed to Opine on Codes and Industry Standards
On January 22, 2022, Sharon Marshall was dining at an Outback Steakhouse in Fort Smith, Arkansas, when she slipped, fell, and received serious injuries. She alleged that she slipped on soup that had spilled in the floor which Outback had negligently failed to clean up. Outback has filed motions to exclude or limit the testimony…
-
Audiology Expert’s “Chart Note” is Not a Proper Expert Report
This case stems from a rear-end, chain-reaction accident. Plaintiffs alleged that, on or about June 16, 2019, Plaintiff Miranda Allen was driving northbound on Interstate 5 in Skagit County, Washington, with Plaintiff J.M. as a passenger in her vehicle. While Plaintiff Allen’s vehicle was stopped in traffic, Defendant Martin Barratt, also driving northbound on Interstate…
-
Credit Reporting Expert May Not Opine as to Whether the Procedures were Reasonable or Unreasonable
Plaintiff Barbara Cooper alleged that Defendant Milliman, Inc. (“Milliman”) violated the Fair Credit Reporting Act in two ways: first, whenit issued a report about her medical and prescription history that mixed her with another individual; and second, when it issued a second report wherein Milliman reinserted information it had previously deleted after purportedly reinvestigating Plaintiff’s…
-
Psychology Expert Witness is Unqualified to Testify as to Reputational Damages
On June 15, 2020, Michael J. Fitzgerald and Ronda and Will McNae finalized a Settlement Agreement to resolve claims related to alleged rape and sexual assault. This agreement included Fitzgerald paying a sum of money and, in return, the McNaes releasing their claims, agreeing not to contact Fitzgerald’s employer, SoftwareONE, refrain from writing about him…
-
Recreational Vehicle Expert’s Valuation Determination Complies with Rule 702
Plaintiff Jason Greene purchased a recreational vehicle (“RV”) from Defendant Thor Motor Coach, Inc. (“Thor”). The purchase included a 12 month / 15,000 mile limited warranty (the “Limited Warranty”). After purchasing the RV, Greene encountered issues with the RV that led him to seek repairs on several occasions. Some issues remained even after the attempted…
-
Data Privacy Expert Has Sufficient Experience in TCPA Compliance and Wrong Number Issues
David Elliot filed a lawsuit against Humana, claiming the company violated the Telephone Consumer Protection Act (TCPA) by repeatedly calling him with robocalls even though he wasn’t a customer and had informed them they had the wrong number. Elliot wants to pursue this as a class action, arguing that many others have experienced similar unwanted…
