Tag: Rule 26
-
Toxicology Expert’s Report Exceeds the Bounds of Permissible Supplementation
Michelle Young, the surviving spouse of Ernest James Young and Amanda Fries, the daughter and heir of Young filed the underlying lawsuit alleging that Young’s death from pancreatic cancer was caused by his exposure to radioactive contaminants that were released by the Defendants’ negligent operation of a uranium processing plant in Gore, Oklahoma, near where…
-
Belated Production of the Accounting Expert’s Report Was Not Justified
Asserting various state and federal claims arising from alleged trademark infringement, Sacks Holdings, Inc. (the “Plaintiff” or “Sacks”) sued Grin Natural USA Limited, Grin Holdings Limited, Grin Natural US Limited, and Grin Natural Products Limited (collectively, the “Defendants” or “Grin”) for, inter alia, trademark infringement. In July 2024, Defendants’ counsel contacted Julianne “Juli” Saitz at…
-
Family Medicine Expert Witness’ Testimony Violates the Basic Requirement of Rule 26
On July 22, 2022, Dr. Gregory Fox, individually and as parent of C.F., and Rita Fox, individually and as parent of C.F. (jointly, the Plaintiffs), filed a lawsuit challenging the state of Maine’s public school vaccination requirements. Dr. Stephen B. Paulding, a board-certified family physician with over four decades of experience in primary care was…
-
Accident Reconstruction Expert Witness’ Testimony Admitted Despite His Failure to Calculate G-Force
On October 24, 2019, William Harrison Sims (Plaintiff) was driving his 2004 BMW 330Ci (the “Vehicle”) in Florida when another vehicle unexpectedly turned left in front of him, causing a minor accident. As a result of the collision, the Vehicle’s front driver-side airbag was signaled to deploy. However, the airbag inflator unexpectedly ruptured and shot…
-
Internal Medicine Expert Witnesses Barred from Testifying Due to Procedural Violations
On October 10, 2023, Kathleen Loveall (Plaintiff) initiated this wrongful death action on behalf of her husband, James Loveall, naming the Government as a defendant under the Federal Tort Claims Act. The Court established September 23, 2024, as the deadline for Loveall’s expert designations. Loveall requested extensions of this deadline three times, without opposition from the…
-
Accident Reconstruction Expert Witness’ Supplemental Report Correcting Mathematical Errors Admitted
Plaintiff Kimberly Allcorn filed a lawsuit to recover damages for injuries from a collision with a tractor-trailer. Defendant Kay Beach, driving the tractor-trailer, worked for Western Flyer Express, LLC at the time. Both vehicles traveled northbound on a four-lane highway with a 65-mph speed limit. Allcorn was in the right lane ahead of Beach, who…
-
Psychiatry Expert Witness’ Rebuttal Testimony Admitted Despite Claims of Untimely Disclosure
Plaintiff Rebecca Leeper filed a Complaint for Damages against the Defendants, the City of Tacoma and Tel Thompson. The case arose from injuries she sustained in a sexual assault on July 17, 2018. In her Complaint, Leeper alleged that the City had prior knowledge of Thompson’s dangerous conduct, including a documented history of confrontational behavior and inappropriate sexualized…
-
Industrial Hygiene Expert Witness’ Calculations of Dosage Exposure to Asbestos Admitted
On October 27, 2020, Plaintiff Robert Stephen Sentilles was diagnosed with mesothelioma. He filed a lawsuit against several Defendants, including Defendant Huntington Ingalls Incorporated (“Avondale”), claiming that his disease resulted from asbestos exposure that occurred from the 1950s to the 1980s. With respect to Avondale, Sentilles asserted that he was personally exposed to asbestos when…
-
Court Strikes Structural Engineering Expert Witness’ Testimony on Hurricane Damage Citing Month-Long Disclosure Delay
Philip and Nancy Fairman’s home sustained severe flooding during Hurricane Ian. After the storm, they filed a damage claim with their insurer, Defendant American Strategic Insurance Corp (“ASI”), to seek compensation for the losses. ASI acknowledged coverage but disputed the extent of the damage. When the Fairmans and ASI could not reach a settlement, the…
-
Defendant Was Not Justified in Failing to Disclose Orthopedic Sports Medicine Expert Witness’ Report Regarding the Plaintiff’s Medical Condition
Plaintiff Deana Hosie alleges that, on November 17, 2017, while dining at the Defendant Omni Hotels Management Corporation’s hotel restaurant, she tripped and fell over a box-shaped object on the floor, causing her serious injuries. After disclosing expert Charles DePaolo, M.D., the Defendant indicated that DePaolo would not provide a report until “after his forthcoming independent…
